• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

IZA Newsroom

IZA – Institute of Labor Economics

  • Home
  • Archive
  • Press Lounge
  • DE
  • EN
ResearchJanuary 31, 2014

Early school tracking: no long-term impact on labor market outcomes

School tracking systems, which allot students to certain school types according to their ability, seek to improve efficiency in education by tailoring curricula to students’ needs. Yet, early tracking bears the risk of misallocating students, as information about their full academic potential may be incomplete at the time of tracking. This risk of misallocation is likely to be higher the younger the age at which children are tracked.

Germany’s school system tracks students at the particularly young age of 10, and has therefore often been criticized for perpetuating disadvantage. However, so far there is no conclusive evidence that pupils who are at the threshold between two tracks (and therefore very similar in terms of their academic potential) experience different career outcomes when they are tracked in a higher versus a lower track. Whether, and to what extent such differences are to be expected depends on a very important, but nevertheless often overlooked feature of tracking systems: the possibility to revise initial tracking decisions at a later stage.

In a recent IZA Discussion Paper, Christian Dustmann, Patrick A. Puhani and Uta Schönberg investigate the effects of being tracked into a higher vs. a lower track at age 10 on long-term labor market and educational outcomes. Comparing students of similar ability around the threshold between a higher and a lower track, they find no difference in terms of completed education or long-term labor market outcomes.

This surprising finding is even more remarkable as these children have been exposed to very different learning environments for about 5 years. The authors show that this is due to the built-in flexibilities in the German tracking system, allowing children to up- or downgrade after grade 9/10 and explaining why there are no long-term effects of initial track misallocation for students at the margin between two tracks.

According to the authors, two important conclusions emerge from this research. First, when evaluating tracking systems, it is important to consider not only the potential misallocation of pupils across tracks, but also the flexibilities in the system that allow students to remedy initial track choices at a later stage when more information about their academic abilities is available. These flexibilities are an important, though often overlooked, feature of the German education system. Second, the research shows more generally that substantial disadvantages in terms of teaching curriculum and peer exposure do not need to have long-term consequences, as long as the education system allows revising initial choices at later stages. This second implication is not only relevant for tracking systems, but for education systems more generally.

IZA Discussion Paper No. 7897 The Long-Term Effects of Early Track Choice Christian Dustmann, Patrick A. Puhani, Uta Schönberg

Share this article

Share on X Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share via e-mail
  • education
  • human capital
  • labor market outcomes
  • school choice
  • tracking system
  • Christian Dustmann
  • Patrick A. Puhani
  • Uta Schönberg
Previous Post
Shuffle
Next Post

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • June 4, 2025

    How workplaces shape the economic impact of caregiving shocks on mothers
  • June 2, 2025

    How administrative data fosters young economists’ careers
  • May 30, 2025

    Raising the glass raises risks for the whole family

Related Content

  • February 17, 2016

    Investing in early childhood development reduces inequality
  • March 14, 2013

    Ten years of “Agenda 2010”
  • October 13, 2020

    School re-openings after summer breaks in Germany did not increase SARS-CoV-2 cases
  • 
  • 
  • Archive
  • 
  • Research
  • 
  • Early school tracking: no long-term impact on labor market outcomes

© 2013–2025 Deutsche Post STIFTUNGImprint | Privacy PolicyIZA